{ "schema_version": "1.0.0", "package_id": "W16", "title": "Capstone synthesis and defense", "language": "en", "phase": "Validate", "essential_question": "What would make the result worth trusting?", "research_cutoff": "2026-08-24", "status": "structurally_complete_text_first_authored_draft_human_review_defense_recording_and_pilot_pending", "required_artifacts": [ "README.md", "LECTURE_NOTES.md", "SLIDE_SCRIPT.md", "WORKED_CASE.md", "TRANSCRIPT.md", "manifest.json", "validate_package.py" ], "time_design": { "status": "authoring_budgets_not_observed_delivery_times", "capstone_total_hours_min": 18, "capstone_total_hours_max": 30, "synchronous_seminar_minutes": 90, "synchronous_studio_minutes": 80, "presentation_minutes": 8, "defense_minutes": 7, "revision_deadline_hours": 48, "transcript_equivalent_minutes_min": 35, "transcript_equivalent_minutes_max": 45, "transcript_planned_total_minutes": 42, "pilot_state": "not_taught_not_rehearsed_not_timed", "media_state": "no_video_or_audio_recording_exists" }, "local_dependencies": [ { "id": "COURSE-W16", "path": "course-site/app/lib/course-data.ts#W16", "role": "Authoritative current title, essential question, phase, capstone duration, outcomes, traceability design, defense sequence, stop rules, and L08 linkage.", "boundary": "A curriculum record does not establish teaching effectiveness, completed defense, grading calibration, accessibility conformance, or external review." }, { "id": "LAB-L08", "path": "course-labs/L08_capstone_evidence_release", "role": "Deterministic synthetic capstone dossier, analysis, traceability audit, checksums, reviewer instructions, and response template.", "boundary": "Automated dossier integrity and local reproduction do not establish independent reproduction, scientific acceptance, legal approval, accessibility conformance, publication, or deployment readiness." } ], "claim_traceability_contract": { "dossier_id": "CAPSTONE-DEMO-001", "claim_rows": [ { "claim_id": "CAP-001", "status": "supported_public_headline", "artifact_ids": ["DATA-001", "CODE-001", "RESULT-001", "FIG-001", "LIMIT-001"], "claim_ceiling": "Descriptive 12-event fixture arithmetic only" }, { "claim_id": "CAP-002", "status": "supported_nonheadline_adverse_secondary", "artifact_ids": ["DATA-001", "CODE-001", "RESULT-001", "NEG-001", "LIMIT-001"], "claim_ceiling": "Adverse descriptive secondary fixture result" }, { "claim_id": "CAP-003", "status": "rejected", "artifact_ids": ["LIMIT-001", "NEG-001"], "claim_ceiling": "No production system causal design or visibility outcome exists" } ], "expected_edge_count": 12, "broken_mandatory_edge_decision": "block_release_and_weaken_or_remove_affected_claim" }, "dependency_boundary_contract": { "bundled_fixture_state": "fully_redistributable_course_owned_synthetic_no_personal_data", "preferred_route": "independent_reproduction_from_declared_release_by_an_independent_authorized_reviewer", "alternate_id": "DEPENDENCY-NR-01", "alternate_state": "hypothetical_non_redistributable_teaching_boundary_no_restricted_bytes_in_package", "required_fields": [ "stable_dependency_id", "issuer", "title", "version_or_retrieval_date", "exact_locator", "lawful_acquisition_instructions", "authorization", "license_and_access_conditions", "privacy_and_security_class", "local_sha256", "authorized_reviewer_role", "verification_method", "reproducible_scope", "unreproduced_scope", "last_successful_retrieval", "refresh_or_revocation_condition" ], "allowed_verification_states": [ "independent_reproduction_after_lawful_identity_match", "controlled_output_verification_only", "unreproduced_claim_weakened_or_blocked" ], "forbidden_public_bundle_material": [ "restricted_source_bytes", "credentials", "tokens", "cookies", "account_state", "unauthorized_screenshots" ], "hash_is_authorization": false, "partial_verification_is_independent_reproduction": false }, "release_gate_contract": { "logic": "conjunctive_hard_gates_no_weighted_compensation", "allowed_states": ["passed_by_named_human_reviewer", "blocked", "pending_named_human_review", "not_applicable_with_reason"], "gates": [ {"id": "GATE-AUTH", "name": "authorization", "status": "pending_named_human_review"}, {"id": "GATE-PRIV", "name": "privacy", "status": "pending_named_human_review"}, {"id": "GATE-LIC", "name": "license", "status": "pending_named_human_review"}, {"id": "GATE-SAFE", "name": "safety", "status": "pending_named_human_review"}, {"id": "GATE-A11Y", "name": "accessibility", "status": "pending_named_human_review"} ], "material_pending_or_blocked_decision": "no_public_release", "automated_accessibility_checks_are_conformance": false }, "defense_and_revision_contract": { "presentation_minutes": 8, "question_defense_minutes": 7, "revision_deadline_hours": 48, "intermediate_artifacts": ["review-findings.md", "response-to-reviewers.md"], "response_fields": ["finding_id", "challenged_claim_or_artifact_ids", "concern", "decision", "change", "evidence_route", "release_version", "residual_limitation"], "allowed_response_decisions": ["accept", "partly_accept", "decline_with_evidence", "cannot_resolve_weaken_or_block"], "revision_propagation": ["analysis_outputs", "figures", "claim_ledger", "limitations", "traceability_export", "response_to_reviewers", "release_notes", "checksums", "run_manifest"], "negative_results_retained": true, "rejected_claims_retained": true, "deviations_retained": true, "failed_reproductions_retained": true, "actual_live_defense_completed": false }, "fixture_contract": { "lab_id": "L08", "dossier_id": "CAPSTONE-DEMO-001", "status": "synthetic_teaching_fixture", "analysis_status": "PASS", "release_validator_status": "PASS", "release_decision": "READY_FOR_HUMAN_REVIEW", "event_count": 12, "metric_count": 2, "claim_count": 3, "artifact_count": 16, "claim_artifact_edge_count": 12, "public_headline_count": 1, "figure_count": 1, "required_file_count": 19, "verified_checksum_count": 18, "machine_error_count": 0, "expected_metrics": { "outcome": { "control": {"numerator": 2, "denominator": 6}, "treatment": {"numerator": 4, "denominator": 6}, "treatment_minus_control": "0.3333333333333333" }, "citation_correct": { "control": {"numerator": 5, "denominator": 6}, "treatment": {"numerator": 4, "denominator": 6}, "treatment_minus_control": "-0.1666666666666667" } }, "human_gates": [ "independent scientific review", "privacy authorization and license review", "human figure and document accessibility review", "8-minute defense 7-minute questions and 48-hour response", "external publication or deployment approval" ], "output_artifacts": [ "release_audit.json", "claim_traceability.csv", "computed_checksums.sha256", "reviewer_instructions.md", "run_manifest.json" ], "claim_ceiling": "automated dossier integrity only; not independent replication, scientific acceptance, legal approval, accessibility conformance, publication, or deployment readiness", "input_hashes": { "scripts/validate_release.py": "a95e5f0e5762545396b22e343d98b8f17470028afd2a74780d6d194781dc1d0d", "data/dossier/analysis.py": "f896e0b49c90937f72e0a28b83193ada1ab22fd139311d1e15bb198510a22e07", "../shared/geo_lab_core.py": "c753847115a751a7e5600c8af2e1d03b538c9e4bc6b0f7d05c3ea495bce92e38", "data/dossier/release_manifest.json": "a0ad3a3de063eb3aec2e8687ca6d8e4bb2f2f0bcf9fe05db675ef50632bb4d45", "data/dossier/observations.csv": "e2545e4f23a3df5171a7e0c24bd6afe80ad58f413d2044df39587bf9a53b335c", "data/dossier/expected_result.json": "b89a31b3bc606778251661766add14590c58332bddfb2a27628339ef903445b2", "data/dossier/claim_ledger.csv": "0b1fad6b5611cd092ee183fadb23bd57031edbd5c230b9daebd2a6da861d1171", "data/dossier/artifact_manifest.csv": "3c54504238ea3213d3073895b260614e3552d0c142fdd27eb4b62c3ec7c0c51f", "data/dossier/checksums.sha256": "b1f3e5ffcb6d9374f3b21cf7c4d2fa6d7ce1e35af5d2209126a8833e67268e2c" } }, "visual_policy": { "external_figure_reuse": false, "external_screenshot_reuse": false, "attached_tex_figure_reuse": false, "visuals": "original_instructional_diagram_specifications_only", "required_encodings": ["label", "shape_or_position", "line_or_fill_pattern", "alt_text", "text_table_when_data_are_encoded"] }, "claim_boundary": { "automated_pass_establishes": ["seven_artifact_structure", "frozen_narrative_identity", "selected_boundary_language", "deterministic_fixture_arithmetic", "declared_local_traceability_integrity"], "automated_pass_does_not_establish": ["human_review", "independent_reproduction", "accessibility_conformance", "pilot", "grading_calibration", "external_review", "recording", "scientific_acceptance", "legal_approval", "publication_readiness", "deployment_readiness", "production_GEO_effect", "causal_effect", "external_validity"], "production_effect_claim": false, "legal_advice": false, "accessibility_conformance_claim": false, "independent_reproduction_claim": false }, "content_hashes": { "README.md": "17b73eff67e828e9aec7a6ca5b95e65b02b891ab73ef4ca67da5e91a67719752", "LECTURE_NOTES.md": "cd3e61ff27daa3ad8ddbf6c9da8b4f0fe1097dada137ae0f12d77339ff497605", "SLIDE_SCRIPT.md": "1d576e2bf504f24b618fd5553a69acf52631bbd6615ce3843e26d05929a497e0", "WORKED_CASE.md": "9dc9a8eac5a114c964e5ecb751558ed6edf4cfbc2b273f9afa67c8ae4cb7ae55", "TRANSCRIPT.md": "fd519fa1f51d56f846d0efa8f3a86276ab244837e87d48b61a0f32ce923e6570" }, "quality_status": { "structural_validator": "passed_2026-08-24", "deterministic_fixture_reproduction": "passed_2026-08-24", "narrative_hash_lock": "passed_2026-08-24", "scientific_human_review": "pending", "independent_reproduction_by_external_reviewer": "pending", "authorization_privacy_license_safety_review": "pending", "accessibility_human_review": "pending", "screen_reader_review": "pending", "live_defense": "not_completed", "timed_rehearsal": "pending", "classroom_pilot": "pending", "grading_calibration": "pending", "external_peer_review": "pending", "recording": "not_created" } }